Skip to main content
Peer-Reviewed Open Access · CC BY-NC 4.0
Home › Issues › Volume 1 · Issue 1 › Article V1-I1-J-2022-0003
🔬 🔓 Open Access ✓ Peer-Reviewed Vol. 1 · Issue 1 · Aug 2026

DNA PROFILING: A MAGIC BULLET OR A WONDERLAND OF UNCERTAINTY

DNA PROFILING: A MAGIC BULLET OR A WONDERLAND OF UNCERTAINTY

KD
Kosha Doshi✉️
Symbiosis Law School, Symbiosis International University, Pune
59
Downloads
787
Views

DOI

📄

Abstract

Abstract:

DNA profiling has attained the role of being an established part of the criminal justice process with high admissibility rates in the courtroom. With the advancements in science and technology, it has acted as a promoter in the shift in scientific innovation, ranging from health, economics, and security; to trade, sustainability and justice. Locard’s Exchange Principle based on the fact that every contact leaves a trace offers a standpoint to DNA profiling based on the promise of 99% certainty and reliability. Unfortunately, the scientific promise of DNA has dark sides in its application to courtrooms. With a backdrop to DNA processes like PCR, RFLP, CAE and  MCE;  the  paper analyzes the DNA transfer stages and profile matching techniques - Comparison, Random Match Probability and the Likelihood Ratio.1 Dwelling into the hierarchy of propositions, the paper offers an insight into the 3 models of DNA interpretation: Legal, Liberative and Scientific. From the legal perspective, the International and National legislative backing is discussed in lines with contested rights of fair trial, presumption of innocence, privacy, integrity and autonomy. This research unraveled the cynicism of DNA profiling by diving into the issues of the CSI effect and the landmark Castro case. Issues of contamination, inaccurate results, error rates, probability statistics, interpretation standards quality samples, examiners’ bias, laboratory slope and the Hardy-Weinberg equation is assessed.2 Miscarriage of courts to uphold the Frye and Relevancy Test are deciphered with an aim to showcase the problem of the ‘infallibility proposition.3Taking from the experience and lessons from judicial pronouncements, the paper concludes with forensic and legal recommendations to uphold the probative and evidentiary value of DNA profiling.

🏷️

Keywords

📖

Full Article

🖼️

Figures & Tables

📚

References

Showing 0 of 0 references · APA 7 format
👥

Author Information

Authors and Affiliations

KD
Kosha Doshi ORCIDCorresponding Author
Symbiosis Law School, Symbiosis International University, Pune

Contributions

⚖️

Ethics Declarations

Ethics Approval and Consent to Participate

Users can freely download, share, and reuse the article for any purpose (even commercially), as long as they give proper credit to the original author.

Competing Interests

Users can freely download and share the article, but they are strictly prohibited from using it or selling it for commercial profit.

Consent for Publication

Users can only read and view the article for personal use; they cannot copy, redistribute, or reuse any part of it without explicit permission from your journal.

📋

Editorial Lifecycle

Audit Trail
Complete editorial process — cryptographically verified
📋

Editorial Process Audit Trail

Chain ID: NFSU-2022-V1-I1-J-2022-0003-CHAIN ✓ Verified · 0 blocks · Genesis 0x9f2b

No History Found

This manuscript has no status history yet.

📅 Total editorial timeline: 0 blocks tracked Genesis Hash: 0x9f2b3c7d8e4a5f1b · Verified ✓
🔐

Verification & Trust

Compliant
COPE · ICMJE · FAIR · ORCID · CLOCKSS
🛡️

Article Integrity Verified

All editorial chain blocks cryptographically verified · Compliant with COPE, ICMJE, and FAIR standards

🔗 Chain Integrity
✓ 0 blocks verified
🌳 Genesis Hash (Merkle Root)
0x0000000025e409354e8cb160424d05350272fc1e
📝 Plagiarism Screening
% similarity · ✓
🤖 AI Content Detection
% probability · ✓
👥 Peer Reviewer Verification
1 verified reviewers (sealed)
🆔 ORCID Verification
0/1 authors verified
🔗 Crossref DOI Registration
Registered & resolvable
📦 Preservation Archives
CLOCKSS ✓ Portico ✓
⚖️ Ethics Approval
💼 Conflict of Interest Declaration
🔐 Verification Standards: This article complies with COPE, ICMJE, FAIR data principles, iThenticate plagiarism screening, GPTZero AI content detection, and ORCID author identification. The audit trail is permanently preserved and independently verifiable.
ℹ️

About this article

📝 Cite this article · How to Cite

View all citation formats in sidebar →
📥 Received
28 August 2022
✏️ Revised
✅ Accepted
28 August 2022
📅 Published
31 December 2022
📄 Version of Record
31 December 2022
📖 Issue
Volume 1, Issue 1 (December 2022)
📃 Pages
(0 pages)
🔢 Article Number
NFSU-V1-I1-V1-I1-J-2022-0003
📜 License
CC BY-NC 4.0
🔗

Share this article

Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content:

Provide free access to colleagues, peers, and your professional network — no subscription required for them to view the full article.

An unhandled error has occurred. Reload 🗙