JUDICIAL DISCRETION IN EXAMIEXPERT WITNESS: ANALYZING THE LESSONS FROM ANOKHILAL VS STATE OF MP
JUDICIAL DISCRETION IN EXAMIEXPERT WITNESS: ANALYZING THE LESSONS FROM ANOKHILAL VS STATE OF MP
📄
Abstract
Abstract:
The final verdict in the case of Anokhilal v. State of MP created an uproar among the public. A man, who had been sentenced to death twice, was finally acquitted by the Special Court of Khandwa after 11 years based, on the same evidence on record; except, the expert witness was examined in third and final trial. The Madhya Pradesh High Court in an appeal against the decision in the second trial, emphasized that when the courts rely on the expert evidence as the sole basis for conviction, they must take the oral testimony of the expert witness, which ultimately led to his acquittal in the subsequent trial. Various Supreme Court judgements had previously highlighted this principle, but to no avail, as the majority of the courts in India still dispense with the necessity of oral testimony before admitting expert evidence. This paper examines the relevant provisions with respect to the examination of expert witnesses in the Code of Criminal Procedure and the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, highlighting the lacunae in the Indian law as underscored by Anokhilal vs State of M.P. The paper subsequently draws comparison with the corresponding UK law and recommends similar legislative reforms to the Indian statutes to safeguard the right of the accused to a fair trial.
📖
Full Article
🖼️
Figures & Tables
📚
References
⚖️
Ethics Declarations
Ethics Approval and Consent to Participate
Users can freely download, share, and reuse the article for any purpose (even commercially), as long as they give proper credit to the original author.
Competing Interests
Users can freely download and share the article, but they are strictly prohibited from using it or selling it for commercial profit.
Consent for Publication
Users can only read and view the article for personal use; they cannot copy, redistribute, or reuse any part of it without explicit permission from your journal.
📋
Editorial Lifecycle
Audit TrailComplete editorial process — cryptographically verified
Editorial Lifecycle
Audit TrailEditorial Process Audit Trail
NFSU-2024-V3-I1-J-2025-0070-CHAIN
✓ Verified · 0 blocks · Genesis 0x9f2bNo History Found
This manuscript has no status history yet.
🔐
Verification & Trust
CompliantCOPE · ICMJE · FAIR · ORCID · CLOCKSS
Verification & Trust
CompliantArticle Integrity Verified
All editorial chain blocks cryptographically verified · Compliant with COPE, ICMJE, and FAIR standards