Editorial Policies / Peer Review Policy
Policy 01 of 15
Peer Review Policy NFSU
How manuscripts are assessed, who reviews them, the timelines involved, and how editorial decisions and revisions are handled.
[01]
Peer Review Policy
NFSU operates a double-anonymous Peer Review process: reviewers do not know the identity of the authors, and authors do not know the identity of the reviewers. Where more than one model is used, the applicable type is stated at submission.
Review parameters
| Parameter | Policy |
|---|---|
| Review type | Double-anonymous. Alternatives: single-anonymous — reviewers see authors; open — identities mutually disclosed. |
| Reviewers per manuscript | Each manuscript is assessed by at least two independent expert reviewers. |
| Invitation response | Invited reviewers have 3 days to accept or decline. |
| Review timeline | On acceptance, reviewers complete their report within 8 days; typical first-review turnaround is 2–3 weeks. |
| Confidentiality | Manuscripts under review are privileged documents and must not be shared, cited or used. |
Reviewer selection criteria
- Expertise match — subject knowledge relevant to the manuscript's field and methods.
- No conflict of interest — no recent collaboration, shared funding, mentorship or rivalry with the authors.
- Independence — external to the authors' institution wherever possible.
- Standing — an established publication record and, ideally, a verified ORCID iD.
What reviewers evaluate
Originality & significance
- Novel contribution to the field
- Importance to the readership
Methodology & rigour
- Sound, reproducible design
- Appropriate analysis and controls
Clarity & presentation
- Logical structure and readable prose
- Adequate figures, tables and references
Ethics & integrity
- Approvals, consent and disclosures present
- No signs of plagiarism or data concerns
Reviewer conduct
Reviews must be objective, constructive and timely. Reviewers must declare any conflict before accepting, keep the manuscript confidential, and must not upload it to third-party or AI tools. See the full Reviewer Guidelines.
Front-end processing schedule
| Step | When | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Submission | Day 0 | Manuscript received through the ORCID-authenticated portal. |
| Screening | Day 1 | Editorial office checks completeness, formatting and scope fit. |
| Plagiarism check | Day 1 | iThenticate / Turnitin + AI-content screening. |
| Editorial assessment | Day 1 | Handling editor confirms the manuscript is fit for review. |
| Reviewer invitation | 3 days to accept | Matched, conflict-free reviewers invited. |
| Review completed | within 8 days | Accepted reviewers submit structured reports. |
Decision process
Decisions follow a defined chain: reviewer recommendation → handling-editor assessment → Editor-in-Chief final decision . Reviewers advise; editors decide.
| Decision | Meaning | Issued | Revision window |
|---|---|---|---|
| Accept | Ready for production, subject to minor editorial checks. | Day 8 | — |
| Minor revision | Small changes; no re-review usually required. | Day 8 | 4 days · resubmit by Day 12 |
| Major revision | Substantive changes; returned to reviewers. | Day 8 | 4 days · resubmit by Day 12 |
| Reject | Not suitable, with reasons provided. | Day 8 | See appeals policy |
The editorial decision is issued by Day 8. For revisions, authors have 4 days to return a revised manuscript — resubmission on Day 12 — with a point-by-point response to every comment. A maximum of two major-revision rounds is normally permitted; papers unresolved thereafter are rejected.